The use of language is said to be reliant on specific developments in the brain as well as in the vocal cords. For this reason, we are told that efforts to train other primates to speak have been largely unsuccessful; that is, apes and monkeys simply do not have vocal cords with the degree of flexibility necessary for speech.
However, these primates have similar developments in the left hemisphere frontal lobe, though not exactly as large as the homo sapiens. In contrast, birds—whose vocal systems are named after the Greek for panpipe—have all the flexibility for speech, but their brains do not match the capacity of mammals.
What is interesting is that anthropologists believe that early relatives of man had both strong vocal cords and deeply developed brain matter. Nevertheless, despite these two things existing in tandem thousands of years ago, we are told that speech only arose much later.
Neuroscientists, taking the hypothesis of anthropologists for granted, have thus formulated a theory that tonal language, or something they call musi-language, developed before distinct words.
The scientist points out that baby language is a sort of musi-language that we, even today, first speak with our children—speaking nonsense in a high-pitch with extended vowel sounds to elicit responses from the child.
Even more interesting for man’s connection with music is that the brain’s right hemisphere is predominately the part of the brain used for examining living things, and it is also the active part of the brain when listening to music. In contrast, the left is associated with the lifeless and inanimate.
For anthropologists and nueroscientists, music is a candidate for proto-language, and we engage with it as though it were alive.
But is this any surprise?
Music is an integral part of our life, and it naturally springs forth within us while we are doing some humdrum task and when we are most excited.
Crucial to all of this is that music needs no interpreter.
Of course, some lyrics may be cryptic if the song has any, but no one needs to be told if one song is happy or if another is sad. Music is not a sign for something based on convention—where in one language, the word for dog could be “dog” and in another, “le chien.”
Music possesses an order and meaning intrinsic to itself; it cannot exist as a jumble of notes and clamorings. Intuitively, any collection of sounds is not music; there is something that unites each of the sounds together.
In Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice, there is a telling exchange between Jessica and Lorenzo as they listen to some music play:
JESSICA
I am never merry when I hear sweet music.
LORENZO
The reason is, your spirits are attentive.
For do but note a wild and wanton herd
Or race of youthful and unhandled colts,
Fetching mad bounds, bellowing and neighing loud,
Which is the hot condition of their blood,
If they but hear perchance a trumpet sound,
Or any air of music touch their ears,
You shall perceive them make a mutual stand,
Their savage eyes turned to a modest gaze
By the sweet power of music. Therefore the poet
Did feign that Orpheus drew trees, stones, and
floods,
Since naught so stockish, hard, and full of rage,
But music for the time doth change his nature.
The man that hath no music in himself,
Nor is not moved with concord of sweet sounds,
Is fit for treasons, stratagems, and spoils;
The motions of his spirit are dull as night,
And his affections dark as Erebus.
Let no such man be trusted. Mark the music.
Music is powerful. It accurately imitates emotions and does not need any interpretation for the listener to possess what it communicates. Music—an imitation of passions shared between man and beast—can soothe and arise so much so that even the animal’s savage eyes are transformed to a modest gaze by the sweet power of music.
But when we consider the music of our day, what do we find?
The sound of music does not only aliven the hills but it is in our cars every time we drive, in our kitchens when we cook, and at our desks, while we work. And, for the most part, the music made today is meant to enflame pride, exaggerate a sexual urge, or embellish melancholy. Can listening to these passionate imitations be healthy?
Before the 20th century, if one were to enjoy music, it would have to come from humming or whistling, or in some way; you would have to make it yourself (for the most part). In this case, many times, the music that comes forth is a reflection of one’s emotional state. Before headphones, no individual could constantly manipulate and excite one’s emotions with such regularity. Music begins as an overflowing, entering the listener and becoming something shared. In this way, the delight derived form music is a common good, one that does not diminish when shared. Music can have a powerful effect if the listener is not distracted by other things—and it reinforces the passion of its player.
Because of its deep connection with passion, it is clear that music is deeply connected with virtue and vice, themselves the proper and improper ordering of passions.
As I have mentioned, music does not simply signify a passion. It imitates them. Consequently, music imitates virtues and vices which are themselves passions rightly or wrongly ordered.
It is because of music’s close imitation of virtue or vice that music is so crucial for one’s moral formation. And this is why Socrates banishes music from his Republic; he finds music too powerful when manipulating the passions and forming the virtues of his citizens.
When we listen to music representing vice, we delight in viciousness. As Aristotle says in book VIII of his Politics, “virtue consists in rejoicing and loving and hating aright, there is clearly nothing which we are so much concerned to acquire and to cultivate as the power of forming right judgments, and of taking delight in good dispositions and noble actions.”
The man who commits adultery in his head is likelier to commit adultery in his bed. If someone delights in the imitation, it is all the more that he will delight in the thing itself. As Christians, we understand that we must guard our thoughts and actions, as most bad actions begin as a fantasy.
If the music one listens to imitates vices, then an opportunity is missed to help form or fortify what is beautiful. We must be diligent when listening to or allowing our children to listen to music. Music is linked to the nature of man—a truth the philosophers saw and something now deeply confirmed by modern research. Let us mark the music.


Responses
[…] Read more…. […]