Does the famous “Divided Line” at the end of Book VI of the Republic express the truth of things? Yes, and most profoundly. Plato’s understanding can be summed up by the word participation. Everything that exists participates in being. What this means is that nothing that exists is the fullness of being, is perfectly self-sufficient, is self-grounded. Everything is and is not, in some respect and to some extent. That which is not subject to these limitations and contingency doesn’t exist, as a being, but is being itself, so to speak, or as Plato puts it in Book VI, is “beyond being.” It does not participate, but is that which is participated.
The divided line is meant both to categorize the participation of beings according to their level of participation along with their respective levels of awareness, or consciousness, or knowledge. Debate has been never-ending on the precise nature of these levels of being and knowledge, with some philosophers and philosophical traditions rejecting participation tout court, but for the philosophia perennis, that is to say, the tradition begun by Plato and Aristotle, Christianized by Augustine and Aquinas, deepened and extended in the modern era, and continued unto today by those relatively few academic philosophers apprenticed to it, participation is its very essence and sine qua non.
In ordinary terms, participation is just the experience we all have of the contingency of all things, that nothing that we experience is the fullness of what is, that when we encounter a good that we desire, there is implicit in this desire an awareness of and a desire for the whole good, for the unlimited and infinite. Things are, yes, but they are not all they could be, and they point to something else that is in a fuller and more complete way; though we can’t quite grasp fully (or at all?) what that might be with our limited concepts, but we know it must be in some sense, and perhaps we can encounter this “Sun” and “Good” and “One” and “know it as it is in itself” through and at the end of the dialectical ascesis Plato prescribes to the Philosopher.
I like to use as an analogy for participation the Incarnation. When the Apostles encountered Jesus, on one level of awareness they were encountering a finite human being dwelling in time and space. And He was this. But His particular human nature, as all human natures are, is a “participation” in the “form” of humanity itself. Here is another level of awareness and being. At yet another level, His humanity (and only His humanity) is a participation in the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity. And at the highest level, His very person was and is and ever shall be God, not merely a participation in God, but God Himself. In Plato’s terms, here standing in front of the Apostles was literally the universal and absolute and eternal Good, but also, a particular and finite and temporal good. The Form of the Good, the highest reality on the divided line, somehow became one of the lower realities on the divided line, while remaining the highest.
When you “see” something, you are always seeing, or potentially seeing, more than that something, for everything is both itself and more than itself. A material thing existing in time and space just is the spiritual or purely intelligible and immaterial “form” it participates in, but now seen and existing on a lower level of awareness and being. And these immaterial forms indeed exist, but on a level of awareness and being that eludes us–we can’t seem to grasp them without mediators–and perhaps they can’t even exist as substantial beings without mediators?–and the mediator of Being is matter, time, and space, and perhaps forms embodied in matter; the mediators of knowledge are our senses, light, water, and air, sensible images, and abstract concepts. The mediator of God, the Form of all Forms, was the human body and soul of a Jewish carpenter who lived 2000 years ago, and it still is and always will be, though we are promised in heaven to be able to “see Him as He is.”
For Plato, a Form cannot both be itself and that which participates in it, for it would taint the perfection of the Form. And this is why many ancient Platonists living after the Incarnation, such as Plotinus, didn’t accept the Incarnation. It’s one of the reasons St. Augustine had such a hard time. Even though Platonism can help us understand the Incarnation, ultimately Platonism must be purified and expanded, perhaps even broken open, by the philosophy-and-world rupturing excess of Being known as the Gospel.


Responses