I have long found it interesting to examine the gaps which exist between our most sacred stories and the reality we cultivate for ourselves. What are our legends and narrative arcs if not powerful idealizations of our most intimate longings? In the West, our stories have lingered in the mediæval period. In a sense, most of our narratives, settings, and characters grow out of the Middle Ages, even when transplanted into different contexts. For instance, the pillars of our most foundational tales include, in some form at least: the honorable and chivalric hero (a knight, if you will); the slaying of fantastic beasts by said heroes; sinister sorcerers who dabble in black magic in their lust for power; provincial settings with modest communities who require external protection from outside threats; a journey set in motion in order to bring back the harmony of the status quo (a yearning for stability); and/or the ubiquity of the kingdom and the cause of installing the rightful ruler to his throne.
The homecoming of the good king or the rise of the prince to his kingship are incredibly deep-rooted and ancient themes which inform our cultural ideals. We know innately when the true king has assumed his role, and we feel the justness of his reign. For only a handful of examples, consider The Return of the King’s cathartic conclusion to Tolkien’s trilogy; the rise of Simba as rightful king at the end of Disney’s The Lion King; Arthur’s moment of election as he alone can draw the sword held in the stone; and the restoration of the palace and its prince in Beauty and the Beast, returning things to a state of felicity and order. Somehow, we know the good king from the villainous imposter and take for granted the legitimacy of the kindly ruler. The rescue and restoration of King Thèoden in The Two Towers is another exceptional example of this intrinsic affinity for the lawful ruler.
What do these stories, simple and gratifying (if not utterly intuitive), have in common? They are all fantasy; fiction; not real. It is interesting that although the fixtures of castles, knights, and serfs have been left in the past, and although witches and dragons might be things of myth, there is some facet of our collective consciousness which remains in an era when kings ruled the land. Yet, it seems that we have come to feel that royalty too is either an anachronism or plain fantasy. In our modern ideals, we have come to a strange and dissonant place where we innately intuit and relish the monarchical system but have retired it in light of our democratic and republican values. Thus, these tales are fantasies in two ways: they star fictional heroes in made-up places, and they allow us to dream of a world ruled by kings, which we find deeply rewarding. And yet, despite that satisfaction, we would never admit that this is the system we desire for ourselves. For some reason, we reminisce about these simpler days of absolute rule by hereditary monarchs while scoffing at the notion that we should ever be subjects of one. Our imaginations linger in these georgic times – and the virtues of the time remain clear – but the self-righteous reflex towards dismissing the so-called ‘Dark Ages’ prevents us from coming to terms with what has been lost.
I find this to be a very revealing thing about people and modern society. I think it is telling that our hearts remain in a time of kings and queens. I think it is important to acknowledge that deep down we recognize the justice in the singular ruler and that we acknowledge some inherent validity to his rule. I think we might notice that in some ways the most glaring critiques of contemporary society and the most nostalgic setting for our mythology is found in this system. Our ideals of manhood resemble the honor and bravery of knights and the cheerful comradery of the mead hall; our ideals of piety are the Catholic system of the mediæval friar; our picture of the ‘simple’ or ‘good’ life in no small way centers around family-run farms nestled in a village, bustling and productive, and brimming with Christian charity. We picture people whose lives are moored by the church at the heart of their hamlet; people whose worries do not extend outside from thence; people who toil for their subsistence and derive joy and fulfillment within an intensely conservative culture. And of course, within its context, we must also accept that the monarchical system did not stop at the earthly: indeed, the Great Chain of Being was the hierarchy extending from the material world, through the celestial and up to Heaven, atop which Christ reigned as King of all. As such, men might best be organized in emulation of this structure; the full realization of this being the sovereign warrior-king blessed by the Church in his absolute rule of the realm. At its most Christian, the West was undeniably most monarchical. Furthermore, the Catholic system, during its golden age in Europe, encompassed the full breadth of humanity precisely because it spanned to include monks sworn to vows of poverty as well as the ruling classes and monarchs; both the Franciscan habit and the royal mantle.
Therefore, I hazard to suggest that perhaps we are now so settled into our era of representative republics and liberal democracies (and of course mechanized tyrannical dictatorships), that we have lost sight of the very real possibility that we might once again find refuge in the comfort and stability of the absolute monarchy. In some sense, we traded much of the satisfaction found in faith and community, and in the local minutia of an agrarian existence, for the ‘rights’ and ‘liberty’ to try to create it for ourselves; a project which, if the state of modern man is any indication, has failed abysmally. There is something natural, essential, and profoundly correct in the stories we tell ourselves about rightful sovereigns. We all seem to have the yearning to bend the knee and pledge our sword to a mighty but beneficent king. We all, in our hearts, understand that there is something timeless and foundational about the monarchical system; something mythical and heroic in ‘king’, which ‘elected representative’ will never have. We all feel the cause of king and country, whether we realize it or not. If we are so willing to retell these tales for centuries and revisit their morals, why do we resist admitting that these heroes need not be a fantasy, and that it is only a matter of conflicting values which prevent us from acknowledging our desires? Perhaps, as residents of post-regicidal and revolutionary age, we have come to consider ourselves somehow better than our feudal ancestors: far too noble in our own right to be the mere subject of an absolutist king. Yet, our most treasured stories belie this: we have held tightly to our royals for centuries as we retell their adventures. So, we seem to know who ought to be king and what makes a good monarch, and there is no shortage of heroic and benevolent kings to aspire to. Are we willing, in taking stock of the present state of things, to concede our error and return to a system of virtue so grand that we have forgotten such heights could be reached by men?


Responses